10
Feb
2008
Posted by Mihaela Lica as Featured
If you're new here, you may want to sign up for email alerts or to subscribe to my RSS feed.
When the Web burns with news about Microsoft and Google dueling for Yahoo! I’d like to present a different scenario.
Yahoo.com is the most visited website in the world – at least according to Alexa. However, its position on the market is even more powerful than we realize at the first glance. We are not talking here only about Yahoo.com.
When Microsoft buys Yahoo! everything owned by this company will be under Microsoft’s authority. When I say everything, I mean everything: your email@yahoo.com, your flickr account, your MyBlogLog account, your Yahoo! Groups and GeoCities, your del.icio.us bookmarks and much more - Hotjobs, Inktomi, Overture to name just a few.
Microsoft has nothing, literally nothing, of such great potential. Yet Yahoo! is in decline?
The online marketing expert already knows what happening here: Yahoo! is the victim of its own strategic mistakes. The Internet is not a billboard display – but Yahoo!’s marketing team ignored this aspect, and the company gave away too many freebies on top of that. On one hand this is a positive aspect – it increased the value of the Yahoo! brand, while on the other hand Yahoo! spent too much money on acquiring these services.
The idea was to provide these for free and to make money from ad revenue, but what works for Google doesn’t necessarily work for all online ventures. Of course this is only one piece of the puzzle – there are many reasons behind Yahoo!’s decline and I’ll let the analysts have a go at explaining how stupid Yahoo’s strategy has been.
Although the value of the Yahoo! shares is in decline, the value of the brand is still strong.
Yahoo! is a name in the industry and don’t forget that it has the second most popular search engine in the world. It’s amazing and sad to see such a company at the mercy of Microsoft and Google. Yahoo! is popular because it is very user centric. Personally I’ve never heard of someone wanting to create the next “Yahoo! killer” – probably because a vast majority of people have always seen Yahoo! as the second best after Google - and a comparison between the two is almost unfair.
The ordinary user thinks of Google and Yahoo in terms of “search engines.” The investors see the search applications of the two as a small part of the whole, and this is probably what we should do too.
Microsoft is not trying to buy a search engine because they already have one. Microsoft is trying to buy the reach Yahoo! achieved in more than 10 years of existence, which is more vast than Microsoft can ever achieve. What Microsoft has now is a fantastic opportunity and amazingly they are about to blow it because instead of making a fair offer Microsoft undervalues Yahoo! A rejection was imminent.
Given that Yahoo! rejected Microsoft’s offer we can only expect Microsoft to come back with a higher bid. What I think though is that Yahoo! has fair chances on its own and instead of surrendering to Microsoft it could remain independent, change its marketing strategy and eventually acquire some new ventures to cover what’s missing from its portfolio.
To make a long story short, instead of accepting any other bids from Microsoft, Yahoo! could try enforcing its online position through some smart, unexpected investments. The company needs a change of vision, meaning also a change of personnel. Even with its current reach Yahoo! still has enough power to put down Microsoft.
A small fish (a motivated one) can eat a big fish -it’s just a matter of strategy and determination.
11 Responses
Alina Popescu
February 10th, 2008 at 8:13 pm
1Great piece Mig! I also believe Yahoo! would be better off without Microsoft. With the right roadmap for both marketing and acquisitions, they could become a way stronger competitor and make Google shiver a little
Mihaela Lica
February 10th, 2008 at 9:55 pm
2I already suggested a change of personnel - and I already know one PR little geek they could use
What if they come tomorrow saying: Alina, we need you :D?
Interesting Posts Around the Web - Feb 11 | Interesting Observations
February 11th, 2008 at 7:55 am
3[...] The Small Fish Eats the Big Fish Paradox @ Ewriting Pamil Visions [...]
Monday Morning Link Love : The Article Writer
February 11th, 2008 at 12:06 pm
4[...] The Small Fish Eats The Big Fish Paradox @ Pamil Visions’ eWritings [...]
Phil Butler
February 11th, 2008 at 9:52 pm
5Excellent as always, I just wish they would let ou ryun Yahoo…..but then smart moves have not been in the cards for them in some time.
Always,
Phil
Deborah
February 11th, 2008 at 11:43 pm
6MS could certainly use your talents for recognizing the realities of it all, Mig
Sueblimely
February 12th, 2008 at 4:00 am
7Firefox was a small fish who took on schools of sharks as was Google in its early days,but maybe the big fish have learned from this and it is not so easy to take them on now. As you say, they gobble up anything promising almost as soon as they are spawned.
I still believe that clever little fish can succeed though if they can find their way out of the shoal.
Mihaela Lica
February 13th, 2008 at 5:47 pm
8OMG, Deb! You made me blush. That was a very nice compliment, thank you. Yet I doubt that Microsoft would ever look at such a little PR.
Mihaela Lica
February 13th, 2008 at 5:49 pm
9You are right Sue. Yet somehow, Firefox is still behind Internet Explorer in regards to market share. But what you note stands: Google learns from the users. This is what makes it great.
g00db0y
February 16th, 2008 at 12:10 pm
10Well this is how the world operates, the big fish swallow the small one. In my personal opinion, Yahoo will be better off without Microsoft, it operates more efficient.
Soli
February 28th, 2008 at 7:10 pm
11Ha! Ha! Ha! The picture over there is really funny, what a way to picture the whole issue. But in my view I think Yahoo! is better alone because I don’t see anything spectacular happening to the entity if Microsoft should acquire it.
RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI
Leave a reply
previous post: The Higher You Climb, the Less That You Know
next post: You Are a Part of My Life
to top of page...