The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde

Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde.Imagine the following scenario: you are a faithful reader of a high quality blog. It’s a multi author blog and most of the articles are brilliant. The blog is more of an online magazine – a news source of sorts – and it is also one of the few you read periodically. Suddenly the quality drops. The authors become lazier, the comments start dancing in front of your eyes and you wonder why.

No, you are not drunk, although as things go on you wish you were. You didn’t take any hallucinogenic substances either. You are perhaps too demanding, because you care about your time, but this doesn’t change the sad truth that the blog in question has something rotten going on. The only explanation I could come up with is the “Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde.”

There is a reason for you to keep on reading that blog: some of the authors are still delivering the kind of quality you expect.

But even there you notice a strange phenomenon. I’ll call it patting. Comments patting, to be more specific. This is when the authors of the same blog comment on each other’s entries and engage in internal debates to make the comments box look busy. In my dictionary that translates:

“Look, I wrote another piece of bad literature. But if you pat my shoulder and you make it look interesting, I’ll return you the favor my dear colleague when you screw up.”

Then you assist to the whole process of patting, teasing, taunting, scratching each other’s back. Full comment madness.

You stay in front of your monitor reading the crap and you wonder why not surf away to never return to that URL? Yet there’s something keeping you there like a strange evil force. You want to see what comes next, when do they stop, when do they finally realize their little game is ridiculous and fruitless.

But wait that’s not all! One of the authors even asks her husband to contribute. And imagine this: the lovely pair, sitting side by side comment crazy, typing and sweating their way into spicing up the comments box, each playing a role. It all appears as if two complete strangers (author and reader) debate over a topic of maximum interest. They argue. They agree. She writes a bad article. A real commentator this time wonders what went wrong. That blog used to be good. The husband comes to rescue the damsel in distress. You watch in shock and even see the order of the comments changing at refresh. Someone is covering some tracks here. You know.

It’s entertaining. It’s like seeing Jekyll and Hyde for the first time. A good blog gone bad because the editor just lost it. Because the editor doesn’t care anymore. There are other priorities in life, aren’t there?

Then it hits me! I know what happens with the blog. It is not the editor. It is strategy. The blog lost its quality, remember? Good authors left it for better gigs. So how to keep at least some readers? Entertain them!

Now I laugh. I remember one of Lorelle’s evil entries and I cannot help but quoting one of her “advices” here:

When I’ve published something on my blog, I log out and then leave comments pretending I’m someone else. I say great things about what I’ve wrote – er, the blogger wrote – and stir things up if the post is really boring. You know, like add some jazz.

You know, you can’t write like awesome every time, so it’s important that you get the comments going so people will have at least other comments to talk to. Besides, it like breaks the ice, you know. These dumb twits who read blogs, they need some butt kicking to leave a comment, don’t they?

Sadly Lorelle’s “evil advice” (which was pure parody at the address of the bloggers who really engage in such practices) is the cruel reality that hit the blog we were talking about.

Comments

  1. I’m glad I’m not the only one who notices this comment crap. You are so right on. It’s like they have nothing new to say and so they start something in the comments. SIGH.

    Well done! Touche!

  2. “These dumb twits who read blogs, they need some butt kicking to leave a comment, don’t they?”

    What about the dumb twit who pretends to be someone else?

    Lu

  3. okay, I haven’t come across a multi blogger blog that went bad like this :) May be you can let us know (without giving them a link, so they wouldn’t know who you are talking about :))

    If someone does that, I think its NOT a shame, I think its desperation and no one needs to be desperate to write a blog… I blog because I enjoy doing it – sure I’d like to see people engage in comments but if they don’t, write another good entry and move on!

  4. Hi Lorelle,

    The blog in cause has more other issues – and of course, they fail to listen to their readers.

    Mig

  5. Lu, the dumb twit who pretends to be someone else remains dumb! LOL.

  6. Pearl, the I best I could do is to give them first a fair hint that something smells there. If they don’t get it I have no fear actually naming them. :)

  7. Where do you put blogs written by one author that use multiple fake names?

  8. OMG Steve! I think this is a matter of debate for tomorrow. Don’t give me ideas. LOL! You are absolutely right, they fail in the same category.

  9. Uhhh hum! I can only comment on the rather ludicrous behavior of others as I am the worst commenter on the planet. What surprised me most is that anyone would argue with Mig in the first place. :)

    She is a tiger in sheep’s attire.

  10. It is so cool and thrilling to be experiencing the same thing I am criticizing in this entry, Phil! I mean… write me a note next time :P

  11. If I could just get one of those post it notes from over there without being bopped on the head I would not find it necessary to utilize bad comment practices. :(

  12. Now isn’t this entertaining?

  13. I know of a site with deteriorating content that typifies the sort you are talking about. The only difference is that there are no ‘ring-ins’ commenting, there are rarely any comments at all.

    You know it never even occurred to me to artificially boost comments this way. Thanks for the idea.

    I am joking, as you say it would probably be very obvious – as well as being unethical.

  14. It’s cool and it’s make me feel uncomfortable at night.

  15. Sockpuppetry…truly the mark of the desperate. I’ve seen something similar occur at a blog I visit. How very sad. Good article.

  16. Ah Sue, I think we are both talking about the same site. :)
    About yours, not to worry. I will come there and make ten comments under 10 different names if you need it. LMAO.

  17. Hi Chiba. Yes, it is sad. Maybe we should make a list of such blogs, to warn the readers. Something like: blogs not worthy of your time.

    Personally I have decided never to read the blog I am talking about again.

  18. Hi Mihaela. ha! A list of sockpuppetry-prone blogs would have all the puppets out in force complaining to themselves. I can imagine the comments!

    I stopped reading the blog I was taking about when I saw a diarist having a so-called high brow discussion on the merits of the diary they wrote with their husband. LMAO

  19. LOL, Chiba! Then we are probably both talking about the same blog.

  20. I found that part where you wrote about a “lovely pair, sitting side by side comment crazy, typing and sweating their way into spicing up the comments box, each playing a role” funny. But, how are the readers going to know that? I wonder.

  21. this stategy would not work with me. I have a nasty habit of not reading other comments. I don’t care what others think–just what I think. ;)

  22. Comment ethics are almost absence on web.Only pro bloggers always cares about quality. May be you should take time to write a post containing list of all crappy blogs.I am sure it be of great interest as well.

    Ashutosh P’s last blog post..What are Keywords

Trackbacks

  1. [...] twist on the subject from Mihaela Lica of Pamil Visions’ eWritings in the article, The Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde: Imagine the following scenario: you are a faithful reader of a high quality blog. It’s a multi [...]

  2. [...] another, as appropriately outlined by LorelleVanForsen of the Blog Herald. For my part, and that of Mihaela too, leaving negative or inflammatory comments on any blog is quite outside both our attitudes and [...]

Leave a Reply

%d bloggers like this: